The three most expensive retirement income mistakes I see are pulling from the wrong account first, wasting the low-income "gap years" before Social Security and RMDs begin, and letting required minimum distributions arrive as a surprise at 73. Each one can push a couple into a higher tax bracket than they needed to be in. Together, they can cost tens of thousands of dollars.
I work with families in the retirement transition every day, and the same pattern comes up. The families who keep more of what they saved aren't always the ones who saved the most. They're the ones who planned their withdrawal order five to ten years ahead.
Key takeaways
- The biggest account isn't automatically the right one to draw from first.
- A common tax-aware order: taxable accounts, then traditional IRA or 401(k), then Roth.
- The years between retiring and starting Social Security or RMDs are often the best time for Roth conversions.
- RMDs begin at 73 for most retirees today and are taxed as ordinary income.
- Planning the sequence years in advance usually lowers lifetime taxes.
Mistake 1: Pulling from retirement accounts first
The instinct is to draw from whichever account has the biggest balance, and that's usually the IRA or 401(k). But every dollar out of a traditional retirement account is taxed as ordinary income.
A more tax-efficient sequence often looks like this:
- Taxable brokerage accounts first. Only the gain is taxed, often at lower long-term capital gains rates.
- Traditional IRA or 401(k) next. Taxed as ordinary income.
- Roth IRA last. Qualified withdrawals are tax-free, and leaving the Roth alone gives it the most time to grow.
This order isn't always right. Sometimes it's better to blend withdrawals from several accounts each year to fill a low tax bracket on purpose. The point is to choose the order based on taxes, not on which balance looks biggest.
Mistake 2: Ignoring the gap years
For many families, there's a window between leaving work and the start of Social Security and RMDs. Paychecks have stopped, so income is low and the tax bracket is low.
That makes it one of the most valuable tax-planning windows in retirement, and many families let it pass. Two moves are worth considering in those years:
- Roth conversions. Moving money from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA while your bracket is low. You pay tax now, at a lower rate, and future growth is tax-free.
- Intentional IRA withdrawals. Drawing down the traditional IRA on your schedule, before the IRS starts requiring it.
Watch for side effects. Conversions raise your income for the year, which can affect Medicare premiums through IRMAA two years later, and health insurance subsidies if you retire before 65.
Mistake 3: Letting RMDs arrive by surprise
Required minimum distributions start at 73 for most retirees today (75 for people born in 1960 or later). They're taxed as ordinary income, and the amount grows with your balance.
A large traditional IRA that was never addressed can push a couple into a higher bracket the year RMDs begin, and keep them there. RMD income can also make more of your Social Security taxable and raise Medicare premiums. Spreading that income out over the gap years, through conversions or planned withdrawals, can make the RMD years much smoother.
Planning your own withdrawal sequence
A good withdrawal plan answers a few questions years before you need the money:
- How much will you spend each year, and from which accounts?
- When will you start Social Security?
- What will your RMDs look like at 73 or 75 if you do nothing?
- How much could you convert to Roth each year without jumping brackets?
If you want a clear picture of your own withdrawal sequence, book an introduction call. You can also learn about our financial and retirement planning or read how to stay on track with retirement planning in NH.
FAQs
What order should I withdraw from retirement accounts?
A common tax-aware order is taxable accounts first, then traditional IRAs and 401(k)s, then Roth accounts last. Many retirees do better blending withdrawals to fill lower tax brackets each year, so the best order depends on your situation.
When is the best time to do Roth conversions?
Often in the years between retiring and starting Social Security or required minimum distributions, when income and tax brackets tend to be lowest. Conversions raise income for the year, so check the effect on Medicare premiums and other benefits first.
At what age do required minimum distributions start?
RMDs start at 73 for most people retiring today. Under SECURE 2.0, people born in 1960 or later start at 75. The withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income.
This article is for general education and is not individual tax, legal or investment advice.
0:00Three withdrawal mistakes that quietly cost retiring families tens of thousands in taxes. I work with families in the retirement transition zone every day, and I see the same pattern come up. Mistake number one is pulling from retirement accounts first.
0:16Human behavior wants to do this because the balance is usually the biggest number on the page. But a tax-efficient sequence of withdrawal, like taking from taxable accounts first, your traditional IRA or 401(k) next, and then a Roth IRA, if you have one, last, usually preserves the Roth for more growth and delays those mandatory tax hits as long as possible.
0:40Mistake number two is ignoring the gap years. For a lot of families, there's a window between retirement and when Social Security or RMDs both kick in. Income is low, the bracket is low, and that's the best time to do Roth conversions or intentionally draw down your traditional IRA before the IRS forces you to do so.
1:02Mistake number three is letting those required minimum distributions arrive by surprise. RMDs begin at age 73, and they hit your tax bracket as ordinary income. A large traditional IRA balance, when left alone, can push a couple into a higher tax bracket the moment your required minimum distribution starts.
1:23The families who have planned 5 to 10 years ahead usually keep more of what they've saved. If you want a clear picture of your own withdrawal sequence, click the link in our bio and reach out.
